Home

Calendar

Map
Home
Computing

Library

Search


The Featured Site: Sample Critique
Women's History Month

The following is used with permission from Sandra Shattuck to illustrate the "back and forth" that goes into making a site ready for "The Featured Site." Unfortunately, we don't have a sample of the UMBC Women's History Month calendar before the critique below, but you can find their finished product here or in The Featured Site archive.

Date: Wed, 21 Feb 2001 14:51:43 -0500
From: John Fritz <fritz@umbc.edu>
To: Sandra Shattuck <shattuck@umbc.edu>
Subject: Re: featured website

Sandy,

I've sorta been the scout looking for possible sites, but I coordinate
with OIA. I think this is a good candidate. However, I'd ask that you
consider a few tweaks (mostly usablity, but one for brand):

* A reference (and preferably a link) somewhere that this is a UMBC site.
I think you could even use one of the UMBC logos or navigation bars at
http://www.umbc.edu/Styleguide. Also, should the title be "UMBC Women's
History Month 2001"?

* I find the text labels (WHM, Webtivism, Etvents, etc.) very difficult to
read. Either drop the shadow or make labels change colors on rollover.

* The blue links against black background are very difficult to read, and
virtually impossible to see when the visited link color turns to purple.
This is a site-wide problem.

* I'd center the search box at http://www.umbc.edu/whm/search/index.html

* On the homepage, none of the "click here for more>>" cues on the image
rollovers work. Maybe that's one of the tweaks you mentioned.

* You have some interesting content, and good organization, but I think
some of these nits would make it more usable.

Later,

John

John Fritz
Coordinator of Web Development
University of Maryland, Baltimore County
410.455.6596 or fritz@umbc.edu
http://www.umbc.edu

On Wed, 21 Feb 2001, Sandra Shattuck wrote:

> John,
> I have no idea how the featured website for the UMBC splash page gets
> chosen (so please let me know if I need to speak with someone else), but I
> just wanted to make a plug for the Women's History Month
> website, which has been crafted by two students. They're still working on
> bugs, but if you want to take a look, it's at www.umbc.edu/whm.
> I thought it might be a good website to feature in March. I've been
> working with the two students creating the site. Thanks - Sandy